InsideTrading SEC Form 4 insider trades
← All clusters
CLBK

Columbia Financial, Inc.

Moderate buying: $6.1M bought (counted up to $5.0M); 15 distinct insiders. Holding it back: 43 days from first to last purchase.

63
Insider ScoreThe number from 0 to 100 shown on each cluster and used to rank the lists. By default it is the match score, plus the points of the AI review when there is one. It describes the buying; it is not a forecast or a recommendation. 60–79 · moderate buying
-42.2%
Since the cluster formed, vs benchmark (+57.5% raw)

Score, not a recommendation.

Total bought$6.1M55 Form 4 purchases
Distinct insiders15open-market buyers
Insiders' average price$10.85no price on the purchase days
Cluster window2018-04-19 → 2018-06-01closed

partial dataAn input is missing, usually the market cap or the price history. A missing input counts as neutral in the score and is never estimated. Price history is incomplete; missing inputs count as neutral in the score.

Price and insider purchases

Live chart from Yahoo Finance, loaded through this server; our daily closes when it is unavailable.

Loading price history…

How the score adds up

How each input is counted →
Points each input adds to the score, and how much of the points it could give it has
Input Strength Points
$6.1M bought (counted up to $5.0M)The dollars the insiders bought, a purchase reported jointly counted once, counted from $131. Each tenfold adds 12.4 points, up to $5.0M; more adds nothing. The bar is empty at $10.0K and full at $5.0M. 100% +57
15 distinct insidersHow many different insiders bought. Each extra insider adds less than the one before (the points follow the log of the count: 4.3 per doubling). The bar is full at 10 insiders. 100% +17
A CEO among the buyersWhether the chief executive is among the buyers: 10.6 points when yes. 100% +10
Stock 0% below its 1-year highHow far the stock had fallen from its highest close of the past year, at the close before the buying. Every 10% of fall adds 1.9 points. A fall beyond 30% adds nothing more. The bar is full at a 30% fall. 0% +0
43 days from first to last purchaseDays between the first and the last purchase. Each day takes off 0.11 points: buying close together keeps more. The bar is empty at 60 days. 28% -5
Routine or plan purchases: 0% of the dollarsThe share of the dollars in routine or plan purchases (a Rule 10b5-1 plan, dividend reinvestment, a regular cadence). All of it routine would take off 5.6 points. 100% +0
Largest buyer: Kemly Thomas J. (CEO), 15% of the dollarsThe share of the dollars bought by the largest buyer. Buying spread evenly keeps the points; one buyer paying for everything takes off 12.7. 91% -2
Match scoreA score from 0 to 100 worked out from the dollars bought, the number of insiders, whether a CEO bought, how far the stock had fallen, how spread out the purchases were and how much came from one buyer. Its weights were calibrated on past clusters. It is the default ranking of the lists and it decides which clusters get the AI review. It describes the buying; it is not a forecast.77
Pipeline flagsPoints taken off because the filings themselves show this buying was an offering, a plan or a 10b5-1 programme. Used only when there is no AI review; from Form 4 footnotes, 8-K filings and prices. (IPO or offering)-14
Insider ScoreThe number from 0 to 100 shown on each cluster and used to rank the lists. By default it is the match score, plus the points of the AI review when there is one. It describes the buying; it is not a forecast or a recommendation.63

Why are they buying?

No explanation has been generated for this cluster. The filings in the table below are the primary evidence.

Transactions

55 Form 4 trades · 15 insiders Download CSV Up to 5,000 rows
Purchases in this cluster, grouped by insider, largest first
Date InsiderAn officer or director of a company, or an owner of more than 10% of its shares. The law requires them to report their trades in the company's stock to the SEC. Role Shares Price Value Flags Filing
2018-04-19 → 2018-05-04 Kemly Thomas J. 5 purchases with a 63-day result · median +2.0% CEO 78,000 $11.64 avg $907.9K
offering
2018-04-19 Kemly Thomas J. 8,433 $10.00 $84.3K
offering
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kemly Thomas J. 8,192 $10.00 $81.9K
offering
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kemly Thomas J. 5,933 $10.00 $59.3K
offering
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kemly Thomas J. 24,687 $10.00 $246.9K
offering
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kemly Thomas J. 7,755 $10.00 $77.6K
offering
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-30 Kemly Thomas J. 14,000 $15.59 $218.3K
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-30 Kemly Thomas J. 5,700 $15.55 $88.6K
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-30 Kemly Thomas J. 300 $15.50 $4.6K
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-04 Kemly Thomas J. 3,000 $15.45 $46.4K
offering
SEC filing for Kemly Thomas J. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 → 2018-05-24 Massood Michael Jr. 7 purchases with a 63-day result · median -8.1% Director 48,030 $15.07 avg $723.8K
offering
2018-04-19 Massood Michael Jr. 3,265 $10.00 $32.6K
offering
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Massood Michael Jr. 7,554 $10.00 $75.5K
offering
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-02 Massood Michael Jr. 1,600 $15.58 $24.9K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-02 Massood Michael Jr. 5,860 $15.59 $91.4K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-02 Massood Michael Jr. 960 $15.58 $15.0K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-02 Massood Michael Jr. 200 $15.59 $3.1K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-02 Massood Michael Jr. 2,200 $15.60 $34.3K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-02 Massood Michael Jr. 180 $15.57 $2.8K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-15 Massood Michael Jr. 4,000 $16.35 $65.4K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-15 Massood Michael Jr. 7,000 $16.37 $114.6K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-16 Massood Michael Jr. 3,417 $17.00 $58.1K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-16 Massood Michael Jr. 216 $16.99 $3.7K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-16 Massood Michael Jr. 1,803 $16.99 $30.6K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-23 Massood Michael Jr. 7,673 $17.60 $135.0K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-24 Massood Michael Jr. 2,102 $17.47 $36.7K
SEC filing for Massood Michael Jr. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 → 2018-04-30 Gibney Dennis E. 7 purchases with a 63-day result · median +1.9% CFO 58,000 $10.29 avg $596.6K
offering
2018-04-19 Gibney Dennis E. 10,000 $10.00 $100.0K
offering
SEC filing for Gibney Dennis E. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Gibney Dennis E. 45,000 $10.00 $450.0K
offering
SEC filing for Gibney Dennis E. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-30 Gibney Dennis E. 2,532 $15.52 $39.3K
SEC filing for Gibney Dennis E. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-30 Gibney Dennis E. 468 $15.52 $7.3K
SEC filing for Gibney Dennis E. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Czerwinski Frank history of Czerwinski Frank's purchases Director 55,000 $10.00 avg $550.0K
offering
2018-04-19 Czerwinski Frank 20,000 $10.00 $200.0K
offering
SEC filing for Czerwinski Frank (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Czerwinski Frank 25,000 $10.00 $250.0K
offering
SEC filing for Czerwinski Frank (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Czerwinski Frank 10,000 $10.00 $100.0K
offering
SEC filing for Czerwinski Frank (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Hallock Raymond G. history of Hallock Raymond G.'s purchases Director 55,000 $10.00 $550.0K
offering
SEC filing for Hallock Raymond G. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Holland Noel R. history of Holland Noel R.'s purchases Director 55,000 $10.00 avg $550.0K
offering
2018-04-19 Holland Noel R. 5,000 $10.00 $50.0K
offering
SEC filing for Holland Noel R. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Holland Noel R. 2,000 $10.00 $20.0K
offering
SEC filing for Holland Noel R. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Holland Noel R. 48,000 $10.00 $480.0K
offering
SEC filing for Holland Noel R. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kuiken Henry 5 purchases with a 63-day result · median -2.5% Director 55,000 $10.00 avg $550.0K
offering
2018-04-19 Kuiken Henry 16,500 $10.00 $165.0K
offering
SEC filing for Kuiken Henry (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kuiken Henry 38,500 $10.00 $385.0K
offering
SEC filing for Kuiken Henry (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Van Dyk Robert 6 purchases with a 63-day result · median -12.6% Director 55,000 $10.00 $550.0K
offering
SEC filing for Van Dyk Robert (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kelly Geri M. history of Kelly Geri M.'s purchases EVP / SVP 29,950 $10.00 avg $299.5K
offering
2018-04-19 Kelly Geri M. 1,971 $10.00 $19.7K
offering
SEC filing for Kelly Geri M. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Kelly Geri M. 27,979 $10.00 $279.8K
offering
SEC filing for Kelly Geri M. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Randall Elizabeth E. 4 purchases with a 63-day result · median +1.9% Director 24,942 $10.00 avg $249.4K
offering
2018-04-19 Randall Elizabeth E. 135 $10.00 $1.4K
offering
SEC filing for Randall Elizabeth E. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Randall Elizabeth E. 24,706 $10.00 $247.1K
offering
SEC filing for Randall Elizabeth E. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Randall Elizabeth E. 101 $10.00 $1.0K
offering
SEC filing for Randall Elizabeth E. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Allen, Jr. Edward Thomas history of Allen, Jr. Edward Thomas's purchases COO 24,000 $10.00 avg $240.0K
offering
2018-04-19 Allen, Jr. Edward Thomas 20,000 $10.00 $200.0K
offering
SEC filing for Allen, Jr. Edward Thomas (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Allen, Jr. Edward Thomas 4,000 $10.00 $40.0K
offering
SEC filing for Allen, Jr. Edward Thomas (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-30 → 2018-06-01 Salvetti John R. 4 purchases with a 63-day result · median -5.6% Director 13,000 $16.69 avg $216.9K
2018-05-30 Salvetti John R. 10,000 $16.58 $165.8K
SEC filing for Salvetti John R. (opens in a new tab)
2018-06-01 Salvetti John R. 400 $17.05 $6.8K
SEC filing for Salvetti John R. (opens in a new tab)
2018-06-01 Salvetti John R. 2,600 $17.05 $44.3K
SEC filing for Salvetti John R. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Krukar Mark S. 3 purchases with a 63-day result · median -4.6% Other C-suite 8,800 $10.00 avg $88.0K
offering
2018-04-19 Krukar Mark S. 2,800 $10.00 $28.0K
offering
SEC filing for Krukar Mark S. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Krukar Mark S. 6,000 $10.00 $60.0K
offering
SEC filing for Krukar Mark S. (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 → 2018-05-03 Klimowich John 4 purchases with a 63-day result · median +2.3% Other C-suite 1,992 $11.38 avg $22.7K
offering
2018-04-19 Klimowich John 228 $10.00 $2.3K
offering
SEC filing for Klimowich John (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Klimowich John 1,264 $10.00 $12.6K
offering
SEC filing for Klimowich John (opens in a new tab)
2018-05-03 Klimowich John 500 $15.50 $7.8K
SEC filing for Klimowich John (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Murphy Brian William history of Murphy Brian William's purchases EVP / SVP 1,100 $10.00 avg $11.0K
offering
2018-04-19 Murphy Brian William 100 $10.00 $1.0K
offering
SEC filing for Murphy Brian William (opens in a new tab)
2018-04-19 Murphy Brian William 1,000 $10.00 $10.0K
offering
SEC filing for Murphy Brian William (opens in a new tab)
Total $6.1M

Other buying runs at CLBK

A buying runPurchases at one company with no pause longer than the cluster rule allows. A long pause ends the run, so one company can have several. ends after a pause in the buying, so one company can have several. Returns are the stock's return minus its benchmarkThe index a stock's return is compared with: a small-cap index for small companies, a large-cap index otherwise. (IWM for small companies, SPY otherwise), from the first open after the buying run became a cluster. Past results, not a forecast.

After this buying run became a cluster, vs benchmark: 21 days +11.6% (+13.7% raw)63 days +2.1% (+7.7% raw)126 days -2.9% (+0.8% raw)

Other insider buying runs at this company, newest first, with the return against the benchmark that followed
Window Insiders Total Score 21 days vs benchmark63 days vs benchmark126 days vs benchmark Status
2020-02-04 → 2020-03-13 3 $525.7K 38 +12.5% (-8.2% raw)-14.4% (-6.8% raw)-36.9% (-29.0% raw) closed
2019-06-13 → 2019-06-14 8 $547.1K 66 +5.5% (+6.4% raw)+5.9% (+7.6% raw)+7.9% (+16.3% raw) closed
2019-02-07 → 2019-03-08 6 $429.4K 59 -4.9% (-1.7% raw)-3.5% (-5.4% raw)-3.7% (-5.1% raw) closed
2018-10-30 → 2018-12-07 7 $575.6K 63 +2.8% (+4.9% raw)+2.9% (+3.4% raw)-1.9% (+3.2% raw) closed